9 Comments
User's avatar
Jessica Maison's avatar

Just watched it yesterday. It was stunning. I agree about the casual violence toward servants and staff. So brutal and not really necessary. Or at least, only needed to be done once by each character. But, lead me to paradise - I won't miss the third one.

Expand full comment
Andrew Smith's avatar

Given the scope of the book, I think the films did a great job of showing what they could. Would I have picked different scenes to omit or include? Probably, but not too many. Dune(s) is/are definitely one of the best sci-fi movies ever made.

Expand full comment
Daniel Barber's avatar

Loved reading through this, and loved watching the movie. I have to agree that Dave Bautista could have done with some more screen time (even though I have no idea where they would've fit him in). I thought he pulled off his character really well and (whilst I understand why) I was a little disappointed when they got rid of him. I don't think I've seen anyone else mention it, to be honest, so I'm glad I've got at least one other person to share that feeling with

Expand full comment
Dr. TMR beste's avatar

I'll admit I have a crush on Timothee Chalamet. Did I just say that aloud? I did. Bad me.

Expand full comment
Kate's avatar

You’re a film nerd. I love you. 🤓

Expand full comment
Daniel O’Donnell's avatar

Glad you enjoyed it, Josh 👍🏼

I’m definitely in the minority but I still thought it was a great spectacle but just didn’t have that emotional connection

Chani is interesting. I think they did need to have a counter balance to Stilgar and Lady Jessica being such fervent believers. Again, maybe that could just have just been reflected in Paul’s reluctance to accept the role

How did you find the score? Not too loud? Probably just me being an old codger 😁

Expand full comment
Josh Tatter's avatar

I actually thought it was a lot more subdued compared to the first film.

Expand full comment
Daniel O’Donnell's avatar

So, yup, me being an old codger is confirmed 😆

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 11, 2024
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Josh Tatter's avatar

I stopped reading the books after Children of Dune. It was getting too weird for my tastes. I've been thinking about giving the series another go, though.

Expand full comment